Oxford University Press's
Academic Insights for the Thinking World

6 common misconceptions about Salafi Muslims in the West

Salafism, often referred to as ‘Wahhabism’, is widely regarded as a fundamentalist interpretation of Islam that fuels Jihadism and subjugates women. Some even lump ISIS and Salafism together—casting suspicion upon the thousands of Muslims who identify as Salafi in the West. After gaining unprecedented access to Salafi women’s groups in London, I discovered the realities behind the myths. Discover the six most common misconceptions about Salafi Muslims in the West below:

Misconception #1: They’re all foreigners.

Salafism is often—rightly—associated with Saudi Arabia. Indeed, it was this country’s immense oil wealth that enabled it to spread its ‘Wahhabi’ brand of Salafism abroad from the 1970s onward. But we should not deduce from this that Salafism in the West is essentially an ‘Eastern’ or ‘Gulf’ phenomenon.

Groups that identify as Salafi in Britain are dominated not by Saudi migrants—whose numbers are actually very small—but by young people who were born here or who arrived at an early age. These include second- and third-generation Muslims—particularly South Asians—but above all, young Somalis and Afro-Caribbean converts.

A growing number of young black people, typically with Christian backgrounds, have embraced Islam since the 1990s, with a significant number following the Salafi interpretation. This trend is most manifest in south London, where the Salafi mosque in Brixton (where I did much of my fieldwork) has offered a welcoming base for black converts—some of whom felt socially and culturally alienated at other mosques.

Brixton became known as the ‘revert [i.e. convert] mosque’ and the ‘Jamaican mosque’ during the 1990s. Today, however, it is also host to a burgeoning young Somali contingent, who arrived in Britain after fleeing the Somali Civil War in the 1990s or were born in Britain following their parents’ resettlement.

Salafism, for these British-born (or raised) Muslims, was convincingly ‘pure’ and ‘authentic’ because it appeared to be anchored in something familiar, authoritative, and readily accessible to them—the Islamic scriptures (Qur’an and Prophetic traditions). Many drew contrasts with what they described as a ‘cultural’ approach to Islam—i.e., traditions transplanted from their parents’ countries of origin.

Women wearing niqabs in London. By PaoloNapolitano. CC-BY-SA-3.0 via Wikimedia Commons

Misconception #2: They support Jihadism and shari’a for the West.

While aspects of their purist creed are shared by Jihadi groups, most—probably the vast majority of—Salafis in Europe are explicitly against terrorism. Not only that, but they tend to oppose all formal political forms of organisation, such as political parties and campaign groups. Although they believe that the shari’a is the best system, they do not seek to impose it on non-Muslim countries.

Instead, their (not uncontroversial) mission is peacefully to nurture distinct Muslim identities. This includes a duty to proselytize to both non-Muslims and Muslims who have, in their view, ‘deviated’ from the ‘correct’ path.

In Britain, the ‘Salafi’ label has been associated with non-violent, often quietist groups since at least the end of the 1990s. These Salafis have condemned Al-Qa‘ida and ISIS vocally and vociferously on public platforms—occasionally at some risk to their personal safety and reputations.

One preacher, for instance, encouraged his online followers to ‘mass distribute’ an anti-ISIS leaflet he had written, in which he urged anyone with information about terrorist plots to ‘inform the authorities’. That same preacher reported receiving death threats from ISIS sympathizers.

Misconception #3: They secretly support Jihadism and shari’a while publicly claiming to respect the law of the land.

During nearly two-and-a-half years of fieldwork with Salafi groups, I never witnessed any explicit or implicit support for Jihadism, or calls for shari’a for the United Kingdom. I only ever witnessed condemnation of the former, and express prescriptions to obey the law of the land. While it is, of course, possible that Salafis moderate their speech in front of researchers, it would become almost impossible to keep this up after a few months of regular interaction. That’s why long-term participant research is so valuable.

Once I became a familiar face in Salafi circles, I became less conspicuous and people were less likely to react to my presence. In fact, a few women felt comfortable enough to tell me about their prior sympathy with or involvement in Jihadi groups, such as Al-Muhajiroun, and why they had left these. Other Salafis had actually helped them to understand that terrorism was forbidden by the scriptures.

Misconception #4: They are brainwashed.

‘Brainwashing’ is typically understood as a coercive process that renders an individual powerless to choose an alternative course of action.  Although five decades of research on New Religious Movements have yielded no empirical evidence for the so-called ‘brainwashing thesis’, it is nonetheless often regarded as the primary reason why people become ‘Islamic extremists’.

I found no evidence of so-called brainwashing. On the contrary, I found that the Salafi conversion process was largely intellectual, rather than based on social or other pressures.

Each woman’s story was unique, but all spoke of coming to see Salafism as an approach that made rational sense to them. Typically, I was told that Salafism was an evidence-based methodology, with every single prescription tied to ‘authentic’ scriptural ‘proofs’, rather than to culture or human opinion. This gave the women—most of whom had been exposed to a plethora of Islamic interpretations—the reassuring certainty that they were following the ‘pure’ Islam.

Far from being caused by social pressures, conversion often occurred despite protests from family and friends, and frequently led to long-term rifts in families and friendship groups. It also had little to do with warm feelings toward other Salafis. On the contrary, under the condition of anonymity, many interviewees spoke of the Salafi ‘sisterhood’ as cold, unwelcoming, and judgmental. Others said that their conversion was smoothed by the experience of a strong and supportive community—but this was often only during the holy month of Ramadan.

Misconception #5: They are the uneducated ‘drop-outs’ of society.

Some argue that, while Salafis are not brainwashed, they are the downtrodden, alienated ‘drop-outs’ of society, whose lack of education makes them ill-equipped to make sensible, rational decisions about their lives.

My impression as a researcher was that these women are at least as likely as the general UK population to pursue higher education. Most of my interviewees had already started or finished university, and just one had no plans for further education. Most were also keen to launch or pursue existing careers.

Misconception #6: Salafi women are forced to wear niqabs (face veils).

Coerced veiling undoubtedly occurs in many societies, but I could not find a single case among the Salafi women I interviewed in Britain. I did, however, encounter many cases where women’s families tried to force them—sometimes threatening violence—to discard their veils and gowns, which they saw as ‘extremist’ or ‘the culture of the Arabs’. A few young women confessed to having actually concealed their niqab-wearing from relatives, wearing the veil only when at a safe distance from the family home.

Recent Comments

  1. Hoosein Kader

    Misconception about misconception????

  2. Sean

    Salafism is a cault nad not part of Islam. Salafism totally anti Islam and should be knowna as extrem ideology which hS noting to with Islam , this cault ideology followed by Saudis, Isis, Taliban and all the extrem terrorist groups.

  3. anonymous

    Hi. I would like to suggest another book for you to research. A lot of Non Muslims view Muslim women as oppressed and abused. I think that many (cultural) Muslim women are abused. In contrast to Salafi women who are married to Salafi husbands who understand the religion properly and who treat them with the utmost kindness and compassion. It would be great to see the non Muslim world learn what Islam really teaches about the treatment of wives from the authentic sources. The Quran and authentic teachings of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him), his companions and first three generation of Muslims.

  4. anonymous

    The most important field to research when researching Salafi Islam is the study of Tawheed (monotheism) from a Salafi point if view.This field gives extensive knowledge of our Creator Allah, in a way that is spiritually enlightening, based on proofs. either textual proofs from the Quran and Sunnah or universal proofs that can be found all around in the universe in all the different things that Allah has created. Studying the Names and Attributes of Allah (the Most High) gives so many details about God, details that can not be found anywhere else. Beautiful details that compell the soul searcher to submit willingly to the laws of Allah. When a person reflects sincerely on these Beautiful details and descriptions of Allah they will come to the conclusion that Allah is the Most Just, The Most Kind, The Most Compassionate and The Owner of Peace. Such that there can not be any injustice in His Laws, and such that these laws were only revealed.for our Benefitand such that there can not be any true happiness in this life and the next except through willing submission to Allah.

  5. Amatullaah

    JazakAllaahu khayr @anonymous.

  6. Shamasdin

    The research is so true n updated.I feel much happy after reading it.well done for highlighting the truth in today’s dark world.
    Highly appreciated n warm regads
    From Kashmir(India)

  7. Hudayfa

    Salaam aleikum

    As a revert to Islam myself I want to warn other reverts and genuine Muslims in general of what I believe may be an organised system of deviant individuals and groups impersonating Sunni Muslims including Salafiyyah and may appear to be highly convincing by using extreme taqqiya and may be supported by other groups and organisations in a deceptive charade to deceive Muslims with malicious and criminal intentions- I advise you only for the sake of Allah to be extremely careful and cautious in your dealings with people, even those who may appear to be from ahl us Sunnah and calling to and inviting to Islam.
    I believe this may be a major issue here in the UK and by logical extension may be happening in other places also.
    From my own experiences and from reports I have seen in the media I believe these people may be trying to entrap individual Muslims in criminality or in other ways through marriage, blackmail, threats etc. with one objective being making Muslims leave Islam and for other (religious/political) reasons these people may have and to counter the increasing numbers of people reverting to the religion-please be EXTRA careful in your friendships and relationships and particularly as regards marriage.
    This is not written to incite fitnah/mistrust amongst people but to warn others and make them aware because of what I have experienced and continue to experience as a revert here in UK-from individuals and groups who ascribe to Sunni Islam and from other groups and organisations in the wider community- in what I believe were attempts to entrap me in criminality and through other methods and oppress me into obeying these people who I believe to have evil intentions towards Islam and Muslims.

  8. NusantaraMuslim

    of all the islamic interpretations that i have met in my life, the salafi methodology respects academic integrity the most.
    they don’t just blindly follow without evidence unlike sufism and other culture-infested islamic interpretation where you can be scolded for asking/challenge evidence.

  9. paidin

    You cant be a muslim without being a salfi muslim , A salafi is a muslim who is following the quran and sunnah .
    The ruling concerning those who deny the importance of the Sunnah is that they are kaafirs, because they deny and reject a well-known and undeniable part of the religion.
    The fact is that these people who have abandoned the Sunnah in fact ignore the Quran`s commandments. That is because the Sunnah is an explanation of the Quran and more importantly, the Quran orders Muslims to follow it. Allah (swt) has not only made obeying the Quran obligatory, but also obeying the Prophet (saas).
    The Quran cannot be understood and implemented in one`s life without the Sunnah

  10. Faisal

    Great jop
    Thank you

  11. Ibnu

    Alhamdulillah, I found my way with salafy methodology in Islam, it is the purest form Islam, in syaa Allah if one will look closely and study they too will become Muslims and practice Sunnah in syaa Allah

  12. olagist

    I believe that God knows the best, but i don’t know why salafih in my country discriminate so much though.

  13. Ceebook

    Salafism is a cault nad not part of Islam. Salafism totally anti Islam and should be knowna as extrem ideology which hS noting to with Islam

  14. Earlyanswer

    God id the Greatest

  15. Rlgl

    Such an odd article from a SOAS Professor. SOAS has a long-standing history of neither being overly apologetic nor overly harsh in their commentary.

    The MAAS Haleem/ Oxford translation of the Quran for example is perhaps the best. And it was translated by an individual with ties to SOAS. It doesn’t go out of its way to modify the verbiage in such a way to make Islam sound *entirely* peaceful, it’s not. However it also doesn’t select verbiage that can promote additional violence or sectarianism either. It’s balanced. SOAS work on the origins of Islam and the historical development of Hadith? Fantastic!

    But this? This seems to break that tradition. While it may be true that many of these things are misconceptions… it also neglects to balance the article out by acknowledging that Salafism is in fact a sect that is essentially a hate group when it comes to Shia relations.

    It also fails to acknowledge that this is a sect that is fundamentally opposed to the promotion of free and independent religious thought among Muslims. And we can not ignore that Salafism is fundamentally opposed to the concept of democracy.

    I don’t care how “peaceful” they are, their ideal world is still one in which there is no democratic political system and no individual freedom or deviation from the Sunnah.

  16. Rlgl

    Honestly haven’t us rationalists been pushed around enough?

    The descendants of the Mu’tazila are still alive and desperately trying to save the Ummah. For a millennia we’ve had to endure watching our brothers and sisters raised with no free will, spending their entire lives being trained to believe that they are unworthy to question what they can clearly see is wrong.

    You know full well that these people are oppressed and brainwashed. Not by their family but rather by the non-negotiable Hadiths and Fatwas which they are encouraged to blindly follow.

    Well intentioned though you may be, apologizing for them only encourages the continuation of a destitute Islamic worldview.

Comments are closed.