Oxford University Press's
Academic Insights for the Thinking World

Do I Believe in Ebooks?:
Part Two

Evan’s post last week, Do I Believe in Ebooks?: Part One, stimulated some interesting conversation in the blogosphere and I hope that Part Two, his bold recommendation, will encourage all of us to reconsider the potential of ebooks. I will be at the Tools of Change conference today and I hope some of my fellow attendees will share their opinions with me both in person and in the comments section below.

By Evan Schnittman

In my last posting I promised to delve into my vision of the evolution of ebooks and in doing so offer a dramatic proposal to make them more mainstream and more widely used. I propose that an ebook license be granted as part of the purchase price to anyone who buys a new print book. Yes, you read correctly; the ebook is free with a new print book purchase.

I have come to this somewhat radical idea, not because I am one of the folks who believe all digital content should be free for the benefit of mankind. Nor did I come to this conclusion because I don’t believe there will ever be a place for ebooks. I came to this conclusion after becoming a fairly heavy user of ebooks and learning first hand what is best and worst about ebooks.

My thinking was somewhat influenced by the events of the last couple of weeks. First Steve Jobs is quoted about the Kindle saying “Forty percent of the people in the U.S. read one book or less last year. The whole conception is flawed at the top because people don’t read anymore.” One week later, Don Katz sold Audible, his digital audio platform and online retail store that was to spoken word recording what iTunes is to digital music, to Amazon for $300mm. Audible licenses its platform to Apple for use on the iPod/iTunes.

In my mind a connection was made between these events as I started to wonder if Jobs, smarting over the loss of Audible’s platform, was lashing out at Amazon. Then I wondered if this was a classic Jobs line – deflecting any interest in something and then a year later releasing that very thing. However, this idle speculation ebbed and a more interesting connection took its place – a link established in my mind between ebooks and audiobooks.

I have had many theories over the years about the potential of ebooks. Mostly, I argued that ebook success was predicated on the network effect of a killer device matched to an equally killer aggregation of content. With Kindle and its Whispernet (EVDO cellular) connected store accessible anywhere in the US right on the device, I thought we had found the tipping point for ebook success. While I am still bullish about the chances that ebooks will now thrive, I have evolved my thinking to see that a “thriving” ebook market will look much more like the audio book market than the print book market. (I should mention that I see the parallel only in size, scope, and type of audience, not in market factors, content delivery, cost of production, or experiential preference. Audio books are not about reading – ebooks are all about reading.)

If one looks closely at how people like me use ebooks, you will see that convenience and portability is what drives use. While ebooks have been around for nearly 10 years in fairly usable forms, the devices to read them have been terrible – until now with the recent generation of e-ink readers such as the Kindle. (Yes, there are plenty of people who are perfectly happy reading on their PDA, iphone, laptop, etc – but let’s be honest; they are a tiny and low revenue producing audience.)

The growth I see in ebooks mimics the audio book phenomenon– by connecting readers who commute or travel with the content they crave. Audiobooks have made a marketplace out of people getting book content when they cannot read and has taught people to enjoy being read to again. Similarly, Ebooks are a brilliant option when you can bring everything you are reading with you and an even better option when you can buy instantly wherever you happen to be – just as digital audio downloads onto an iPod have done for the folks who don’t want to schlep around CD’s or cassettes.

The reality is that even if the current audience of ebook users were to grow by magnitudes over the next few years, the total market would only reach 3 to 4% of print. Therefore we must admit to ourselves as an industry that ebooks will always be a small niche player as a standalone platform and make them free with new book purchases.

As noted in the last piece, the problem with ebooks is that they are currently sold only as ebooks – which means they lack permanence and physicality. The permanence issue has more to do with the cult of books than anything. I, like many people I know are can be called “snobbish” about books – like to keep them as artifacts and display them. Furthermore, while the portability of ebooks is amazing, I cannot imagine curling up with a device and reading by the fire… or in bed, or even in my favorite chair. When portability isn’t a factor, ebooks pale in comparison to print books. Ebooks are solely a product of convenience.

So, if ebooks are in fact very much like audiobooks, why should they be free with print when audiobooks are often more expensive than print? Audiobooks are a non-reading experience and therefore carry an additional set of production and talent costs, and have a ubiquity of preferred devices for replay. Therefore audiobooks garner their own unique pricing. Ebooks have nearly none of the factors to warrant their own pricing beyond that of a niche market.

Making ebooks free with new print books will be an operational puzzle that most will scoff at. While there certainly are huge issues to overcome, there are already many initiatives and ventures in place that make such a notion feasible. For starters, publishers and their production companies have for years been outputting ebooks as part of standard production processes. More and more are now moving to the IDPF’s epub XML ebook standard, which means there will be little issue with getting smartly formatted ebooks from publishers. Also with all the competition and noise surrounding repository services by publishers, distributors, and retailers, there will be many options ahead for cost effective storage and distribution of ebooks.

Offering ebooks with print could create significant value-added marketing and merchandizing programs. Publishers, retailers, even wholesalers could dramatically benefit from such a plan as consumers could be asked to join affinity and membership programs, enroll in online ebook clubs, and register with publishers in order to download their books. Want your free ebook? Join our readers club and you can download it. Just a bit of info required – by the way, mind if we email you when a new title arrives?

Big retail and publishing operations would easily be able to start or enhance current buying and discount clubs to include registration that tracks what titles customers have purchased and now have erights. Small stores and publishers could work with companies such as Baker and Taylor and Ingram – the latter of which is already deeply invested in large scale ebook repository development. Even the corner store on Main Street will be able to offer a customer ebooks on their customized corner of a distributor’s website. This will be a key value that distributors will provide their customers.

It goes without saying that used books would of course specifically NOT come with an ebook license.

In the end this could be a marketer and merchandiser dream. I believe moving to free ebooks with the purchase of a new print title would cost or lose the industry nothing in sales as ebooks would still be available for individual purchase for those who don’t want to spend on print. What we would gain is that books – print books – would increase in value and utility. Reading – pronounced dead by Steve Jobs just a couple of weeks ago– could receive a huge boost if it becomes easier and much more convenient. Buying a book and knowing you can always download the ebook if you need it would a very powerful incentive.

Who knows, over time, giving everyone an ebook with the print version may actually create more native ebook readers and expand the market share beyond what we can imagine today.


Evan’s PictureEvan Schnittman is OUP’s Vice President of Business Development and Rights for the Academic and USA Divisions. His career in publishing spans nearly 20 years and includes positions as varied as Executive Vice President at The Princeton Review and Professor at New York University’s Center for Publishing. He lives in New Jersey with his wife and two children.

Recent Comments

  1. [...] PROnetworks wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerpt [...]

  2. jerome

    Great post. Seth Godin, at TOC today, in fact this is exactly what he’s talking about right now, would argue to give away the ebook for free and let people buy the print version as a souvenir.

    Whatever way you slice it, however, free is in the equation.

  3. Charles F. Wilkes

    I agree with this writer yes, no, and maybe. I certainly do not agree than an ebook reader (in my case the Kindle) isn’t appropriate to snuggle up to in bed — in fact it’s the first “book” I have ever been able to read in bed due to being able to hold it and turn pages very easily with one hand. Try that with a dead tree book.

    I have bought thousands of dollars worth of dead tree books from Amazon alone, since I have always found their prices to be cheaper than anywhere else, plus they offer such a wide variety of books they seem to always have what I want. I am an avid reader since early childhood, and I only give my children and grandchildren Amazon gift certificates, since I want to encourage them to read as well.

    That having been said, I now love my Kindle so much, I don’t want to buy any more regular books at all — really, my book cases runnith over. So I will only buy Kindle compatible ebooks in the future. But what of all the books I bought from Amazon, that I now wish were in my Kindle instead, or perhaps “also”.

    So your comments re using free ebooks as a marketing gimmic to encourage buying real paper books, rang a bell. In fact I have been encouraging Amazon to do just that — but not only for new book sales as you suggest, but to match all the paper books I bought in the past which are now available in ebook formats. After all, why should I pay twice for the same book (I also like audio books, but realise that this is truly different from a book in text form only). And this should apply to books I bought from Amazon as well as any paper book I may buy in the future (few I am sure). And if you try (as you do) to limit this to just analog books I may buy in the future, then this would mean nothing to me, as I don’t plan to buy any in the future, except if a book I want is really a color picture book which I kbow is at least today not going to work as an ebook.

    I belive the availability of ebooks to match my regular book library would do a tremendous amount to encourge a much wider adoption of the Kindle and other ebook readers. And this is important to really get the Kindle and other ebook readers to go big time, and not just for avid readers like myself.

    Charles Wilkes, San Jose, Calif.

  4. Harvey Schubert

    I disagree completely with your view of ebook readers. I predicted 8 years ago that paper books were dead and still believe it. We cannot keep cutting down trees to print books. I use the Sony ebook reader and find it easier on the eyes, easier to transport, and can find plenty of interesting books to read through the Sony online store. I have made a personal commitment to never read a paper book again. The ice caps are melting and our planet is on the verge of climatic changes that scare me. This is one small change each individual can make to help our planet. We went from records to cassette tapes to cds and then dvds for music. Why this animosity to this new technology? The format and pricing will evolve but the technology is hear to stay. It is easier for me to carry my ebook reader to work, the beach or a restaurant then say a 500 page book. They sell a lot of books on this planet. The sellers eventually have to be attracted to being able to sell them without the cost of printing them. The only thing missing is a an aggressive advertising campaign from a company ready to profit from the move to this newer technology.

    Harvey Schubert
    ImaginedImages.net
    North Charleston SC

  5. Zach

    I agree completely, but would add that this will only work if the book publishers do not attempt to force DRM on us. Look at the music industry, they’re moving to unencumbered mp3s, the same file format they were fighting and demonizing only 5 years ago. Who’s to say that I will have only one reader, or will always want a reader from the same company.

    Most consumers will do the right thing. I buy a lot of the fiction I read from Baen precisely because I get unencombered files I can dump directly onto my reader, or read on screen, or even print out. All DRM does is put up a barrier for your legitimate customers.

  6. immobilien

    do somebody know where i can find english texter for ebooks? i want to write something about network monitoring etc. if i get feedback – great!

  7. Robert Nagle

    The question about ebooks is not what percent of the market will they occupy, but what kinds of reading will it enable which was previously not possible?

    To throw out a few random examples: public domain fiction, creative commons books, technical manuals and html(rss) to ebook conversions.

    I’m an ebook enthusiast (I help edit a website devoted to ebook technology) but 80-90% of what I read is still from print books. That’s not the point. Now I am able to read a lot of titles which were not available commercially.

    I realize you are not dismissing ebooks as a phenomenon, but you need to remember that the act of reading doesn’t take place entirely in the commercial sphere.

  8. [...] for books when their content will be offered through many channels and via many platforms), but Evan Schnittman’s scenario about the pedestrian future of e-books [bottom line: they should and will, he predicts, be free] seems plausible to me: My thinking was [...]

  9. [...] les livres et les cd’s sont des animaux très différents. Mais je verrais bien 3% – 4%, chiffres que j’avais déjà indiqués, et qui ne sont plus du tout [...]

  10. [...] for books when their content will be offered through many channels and via many platforms), but Evan Schnittman’s scenario about the pedestrian future of e-books [bottom line: they should and will, he predicts, be free] seems plausible to me: My thinking was [...]

  11. [...] for books when their content will be offered through many channels and via many platforms), but Evan Schnittman’s scenario about the pedestrian future of e-books [bottom line: they should and will, he predicts, be free] seems plausible to me: My thinking was [...]

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *